Midwest floods disrupt livestock feed supplies for California farms

Watch as last corn due to Midwest flooding reaches Penny-Newman Grain Co.

Watch as last corn due to Mid West flooding reaches Penny-Newman Grain Co. Chuck Heuring Penny-Newman’s commodity merchandiser, talks about the crisis facing the state in the shortage of feed.
Up Next
Watch as last corn due to Mid West flooding reaches Penny-Newman Grain Co. Chuck Heuring Penny-Newman’s commodity merchandiser, talks about the crisis facing the state in the shortage of feed.

Some farms, dairies and feed companies in the San Joaquin Valley are facing shortages of livestock feed supplies after deadly river flooding in the Midwest closed major railroad shipping corridors in recent days.

Both BNSF Railway and Union Pacific Railroad reported on Monday that they closed down their tracks over severe weather and record flooding in parts of Nebraska and Iowa because key portions of their lines are under water. That’s causing delays in shipments of corn, canola meal, soybean meal, cottonseed and other commodities that are used for cattle and other livestock and poultry in California.

“With multiple washouts and high water on BNSF main lines in the area, several subdivisions remain out of service,” BNSF said in a service advisory to its customers on Monday. A BNSF map showed closures on lines in and around Lincoln and Omaha in Nebraska; Sioux City, Iowa; and Aberdeen, South Dakota. “We are also anticipating additional closures in the next 24-36 hours involving our Hannibal and River subdivisions that run adjacent to the Mississippi River” between Missouri and Illinois.

“Normal train flows are not likely to resume for an extended period,” the BNSF advisory said. “Customers should expect continued delays on shipments scheduled to move through the area.”

BNSF’s service announcements indicated that an average of 154 trains – about 10 percent of all trains on its system – were held last week, an increase of almost 45 percent from the March 2018 average.

Union Pacific’s service map also depicted track closures in eastern Nebraska and northeastern Kansas. While water remained over portions of the tracks in the railroad’s line between Omaha and central Nebraska, “debris has been removed and track structure repairs have begun where water has receded,” the service bulletin reported. The estimated date for reopening that segment of the UPRR system is March 27.

“We have this every year, but it’s worse now than ever because California is in such a deficit of feed except for hay and almond hulls,” said Wes Creswick, owner of Clovis-based feed broker Feed Services Co.

Creswick, whose customers include dairy farmers in the central San Joaquin Valley who mix their own feed combinations for their cows, was fielding calls Monday from farmers who were trying to get their hands on canola meal – the high-protein leftovers from the crushing of canola seeds for oil. “I started out this morning with nine farmers wanting to buy truckloads, but I was only able to get four truckloads, and this is for a commodity they already own and paid for,” Creswick said.

“At a time when dairymen need all the production they can get because milk prices are so low, they can’t get the feed they need,” he added. Instead, they have to find something else to feed their cows. “It’s a game of substitution and it’s not going to be as good as it needs to be.”

Chuck Heuring, a commodity merchandiser with Penny Newman Grain Company in Fresno, said his company and other major grain and feed suppliers up and down the San Joaquin Valley are confronted by the same shortages.

“I don’t recall anything like this before,” said Heuring, who’s worked in the feed business for decades.

Heuring said Penny Newman typically gets eight “shuttle trains” of at least 110 rail cars carrying feed commodities each month. “We burn through these trains in nine days,” he said. “When there are big disruptions that close certain gateways … it gets mucked up.”

Creswick said he believes that while the railroads are experiencing closures, “we’ve had rail delays for about six months” that have disrupted feed supplies. Creswick said that because the major railroads have orders for more trains than they have locomotives to pull them, shipments that generate more money for the railroads are given a higher priority while lower-value shipments like feed supplies sit and wait.

“There’s a lot of flooding along the Missouri and Mississippi rivers that just give them more excuses; they can say, ‘It’s Mother Nature’s fault,’” Creswick said.

Heuring, however, discounted the high-value/low-value shipping theory. “Prior to 1997, we used to receive corn into the state and it was all by single carloads,” he said. “As the industry matured, the railroads said, ‘Let’s get more efficient.’ They began running shuttle trains, a contiguous train of 110 cars or more all with one commodity.”

Lifelong Valley resident Tim Sheehan has worked in the Valley as a reporter and editor since 1986, and has been at The Fresno Bee since 1998. He is currently The Bee’s data reporter and covers California’s high-speed rail project and other transportation issues. He grew up in Madera, has a journalism degree from Fresno State and a master’s degree in leadership studies from Fresno Pacific University.