Did This 'Temptation Island' Couple Secretly Reunite? One Castmate Says They're Back Together!
While Jack Mason and Shyanne Blankenship left Temptation Island season 2 very clearly not together, Mason's villa fling Erin Carter (who goes by her last name on the show) says they've been secretly back together since very shortly after filming ended.
Related: Which ‘Temptation Island' Couples Are Still Together Now?
In an interview with Reality Steve, Carter said that her summer romance continued with Mason after filming, with the pair spending a day together in Hawaii right after the final bonfire where both Mason and Blankenship agreed to walk away from their "toxic" relationship.
Even after getting back to San Diego, where she lives, Carter continued having conversations with Mason, inviting him to visit her and asking him about whether or not he'd been meeting girls in his new single life. However, the brunette beauty got a surprise one month later.
"Recently I found out [Jack] and Shyanne were back together basically the second they got home, and she knew that me and Jack were still talking," Carter said. "I guess about a month in is when they decided to like cut everyone off."
"So then I was blocked from Jack, blocked from Shyanne, and that was it," she said, insisting "they fully got back together, fully are back together," but that they don't want people to know.
In the Temptation Island season 2 reunion on The Viall Filesfollowing the finale, both Blankenship and Mason claimed they were still broken up, but they did admit to having an intense talk one month after filming where they shared every detail on what happened with the singles on the show. They also confirmed they cut off their other connections following the chat.
"I would say that conversation was productive," said Blankenship. "Jack was like, I still want you like in my life. I still want to be friends with you... We've been together for so long that I think that's the best, and that's where we kind of just came to the conclusion of everybody from the show needs to go."
Copyright 2026 The Arena Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This story was originally published April 27, 2026 at 4:18 PM.