What ‘Temptation Island' Fans Didn't See of Scarlett and Bradley's Connection
Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller went on Temptation Island Season 2 to prove that he can be faithful to her. But Scarlett felt like Cole, 27, had other issues to work on in the villa. They dated two years before the show.
There were some scenes of Scarlett talking to Bradley Bobbit in the women's villa. He teared up when they had to say goodbye before the final bonfire. A tempter revealed their relationship wasn't completely shown on Netflix.
Spoiler alert for the final bonfire!
Scarlett and Brad Were 'Seamless' on ‘Temptation Island'
The 30-year-old bartender talked about her anxiety throughout the process. Xzavier Odom said there was more that we didn't see.
"I don't really think they went in-depth as much with Brad and Scarlett's connection," Xzavier said on The Viall Files. "Like, they were locked in like early on. As far as two people, same age range, I don't know about similar upbringing, but same depth communication-wise and just values. They were a seamless pair as well."
Related: ‘Temptation Island': Xzavier Reveals if He Talked to Mikey After the Show
"You f-cking get me," Scarlett told Bradley at a bar in episode 4. "I don't know if it's an age thing." Bradley said it could be, but they also had similar experiences.
Scarlett said in an interview that she learned the most about herself by spending time with the bartender. She wants the same type of conversations in her relationship with Cole.
Scarlett revealed that Cole withheld information from her weeks before coming on the show. She had to ask him if there would be girls on the outing. He revealed that one who was direct messaging him might come because he talked about his plans.
She was disappointed that Cole didn't talk to any of the girls in the men's villa to build that skill. Scarlett decided to leave the island single.
Related: A ‘Temptation Island' Star Was on Another Netflix Reality Show
Copyright 2026 The Arena Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This story was originally published April 14, 2026 at 11:42 AM.