In the mid-19th century Gen. James Henry Carleton ordered 9,000 Navajos to walk 400 miles from their ancestral home in the southwestern semi-desert to marshy land along the Pecos River. He thought he could force them to change abruptly from semi-nomadic hunter-farmers to sedentary farmers.
On the Pecos they suffered terribly from disease, hunger, raids by Comanches and Apaches, and depression -- shock -- from the destruction of their culture. After several years it was clear this relocation was a disastrous failure.
In the early 21st century, George W. Bush ordered the invasion and conquest of Iraq over non-existent weapons of mass destruction. He thought he could force Iraq to change abruptly from a Middle Eastern dictatorship to a liberal Western democracy.
Three and a half years later -- scores of thousands of dead and wounded and crippled and psychologically maimed Iraqis and Americans later, trillions of dollars later -- it is clear that this invasion is in most ways a disastrous failure.
Digital Access for only $0.99
For the most comprehensive local coverage, subscribe today.
The reason so many citizens of other countries consider America an imperialist nation is that too often our leaders have acted as though we had a right to empire. We don't.