You're in the Columnists - ASK AMY: Amy Dickinson section

False accusations amount to child abuse

Published online on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2009

Bookmark and Share
email this story to a friend E-Mail print story Print
Text Size:

tool name

close
tool goes here
Comments (0)

Dear Amy: My brother and his soon-to-be ex-wife have been married for 19 years. They have twin girls who are almost 7 and live in another state. They are going through a nasty divorce in which my sister-in-law has pressed child molestation charges against my brother.

There is no question he is innocent. This is about my sister-in-law not wanting to share custody.

My brother was coerced into signing an order of protection and cannot be anywhere near his children until the case wends its way through the court system.

My daughters, 11 and 9, are very close to the twins. We are traveling to see my brother and lend him support.

My daughters want to spend time with their cousins, so I wrote to my sister-in-law asking if we could get the children together.

She said she'll have nothing to do with me (I'm now an "outlaw") but that my girls are welcome to visit her house without me.

I suggested a public place where we could both be present, but she said no because she's afraid my brother will show up.

My daughters know very little about the divorce. The twins have been coached by their mother, and examined and interviewed by social services.

Should I let my daughters go to their house, play with them, be around their mom and be exposed to the details of the divorce -- not to mention what negative ideas my sister-in-law might feed them about their uncle?

It's either their house, where I cannot see or hear what's going on, or nothing at all. What do you think?

-- Frustrated

Dear Frustrated: There should be a special room in purgatory reserved for people who make false accusations involving children.

Your dilemma shows that the ripples of this situation extend well beyond a dispute between two parents.

Unless you are completely confident your sister-in-law would behave appropriately around your children, then you shouldn't leave them with her.

You will have to explain to your kids that they won't be able to visit with their cousins this time, but you'll make sure they see one another very soon. Spare the details.

The best way for you to support your brother would be to urge him to retain the best legal counsel he can find and fight this.

Dragging children through multiple interviews and examinations and poisoning them against a parent is child abuse.


Send questions to askamy@tribune.com or Ask Amy, Chicago Tribune, TT500, 435 N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, IL 60611.

A few rules are needed to help foster a feeling of community. We encourage a free and open exchange of ideas in a climate of mutual respect, but any post that violates someone's right to use and enjoy fresnobee.com is prohibited. Before you post, please read the terms of use and obey these simple guidelines.

Here are the ground rules:

  1. Be yourself. A nickname will be used for posts, but if an editor finds a user without a verifiable name, that user will be warned or banned.
  2. Keep it clean. Foul language (defined by prime-time standards) will not be tolerated. Neither will the intentional misspelling of foul language or the use of non-English curse words.
  3. Be truthful. Do not lie or link to sites that may be considered libelous, defamatory or false.
  4. Be nice. Don't harass anyone. Don't threaten anyone. Don't use racial slurs. Don't post anything sexually explicit.
  5. Be an individual. Do not advertise or solicit. Do not harvest any information for business use.
  6. Be original. Do not post copyrighted material.
  7. Follow the law. Don't do anything or post anything considered illegal by city, county, state or federal regulations and laws.

more videos »