EDITORIAL: Merced sheriff abuses his power

Merced County's Tom Cavallero digs into lives of political gadflies.

May 23, 2014 

Sheriff Tom Cavallero.


One of the irritating things about serving in local government is having to deal with the gadflies.

Despite having no specific business there, gadflies are the regular attendees of public meetings at city councils, school districts and boards of supervisors.

Some are retired people with a keen interest in local politics -- and strong opinions. Some have a bone to pick with an official or department. Others use the meetings as a forum to espouse paranoid fantasies.

Still, just like any other member of the public, they have the right to address their elected officials without fear of reprisals or retributions. That right has been violated in Merced County.

Elected bodies have found novel ways to shut up the unruly public: adopting civility rules for speakers, severely curtailing speaking time limits and moving public comments until the end of meetings in the hope no one would wait that long to speak. But, at least to our knowledge, no body of elected officials have gone so far as to dig into the background of meeting attendees and share the details of their lives and contacts with law enforcement amongst themselves.

Merced Sheriff Tom Cavallero did just that. He conducted a casual backgrounding -- a "briefing" as he described it -- of three people who had spoken before the board three or more times recently. One is a music teacher at Merced College who seems to be on a tear about sheriff cruisers parking in "no parking" spots; another is a young mother who is convinced her husband is not getting proper medical care in county jail; the third is a woman who has some issues with one particular sheriff's captain. Cavallero apparently used his resources to find their history with law enforcement, checked out their social media pages and then summarizes the findings in a memo to the Board of Supervisors and top county officials.

In addition to details about restraining orders and YouTube videos, Cavallero offered his own, rather derisive observations. Here's an example: "What is remarkable about Mr. Spencer is the level of interest he takes in himself and his misguided notion that the rest of society shares that interest. It appears that he finds amusement in wasting the people's time through frivolous interaction with government officials."

Cavallero said this is the first time he's written such memos, but who really knows? This one only became public because a reporter, Ramona Giwargis at The Bee's cousin newspaper, the Merced Sun-Star, got a hold of the memo and wrote about it.

This was an egregious overstep that won't engender the public's trust in law enforcement. At the very least, Cavallero and other Merced County officials should apologize to the people targeted in the memo. Better that they vow not to take that kind of action against citizens again.

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service