EDITORIAL: This land is your land -- including the beaches

The Fresno BeeMay 19, 2014 

Julie Graves, left, and Chris Adams, second from left, hold up signs in support of a beach access bill that Democratic state Sen. Jerry Hill introduced near Martin's Beach Monday, Feb. 10, 2014, in Half Moon Bay. Adams and Graves are part of families that have gone to the beach for picnics for over 40 years.


California has about 1,100 miles of coastline. This land belongs to you and me.

That's not just a paraphrased folk song. It's a core value. In the 1970s, Californians passed groundbreaking laws to ensure that everyone would have a right to the beach -- not just the rich and connected.

But as once-rustic beach burgs have serially gentrified into playgrounds for the uber-wealthy, coastal access has become an increasingly high-stakes battle. All sides would benefit if we shored up the public's right to its day at the beach.

Today's case in point? The de facto privatization of a once-bustling beach in San Mateo County that has been cordoned off for years by a Silicon Valley tycoon.

For 100 years, Martin's Beach was a favorite of fishermen, families and surfers. Like all of the coast, it is public property beyond the mean high tide line. The family who owned the surrounding land made sure beach-goers had access.

In 2008, though, venture capitalist Vinod Khosla, famed for his green tech investments, bought 53 acres there for $37.5 million via two limited liability corporations. Soon, locked gates blocked the only road to the sand, paint covered the entry sign, and surfers were arrested for trespassing.

Coastal activists and locals felt betrayed. The path to Martin's Beach is the only coastal access for miles in either direction.

Perhaps Khosla felt betrayed, too. Thirty-seven and a half million bucks is a lot to spend just so strangers can cut through your front yard. But sharing is supposed to be part of the price of a front-row seat to a public gem.

Khosla's lawyers claim that the road is his to close; if people want to visit their mean high tide line, they can do it by water.

Litigation, which made news recently as Khosla took the stand only to dodge questions, has dragged on for years through multiple lawsuits. It may seem outrageous, given the spirit of the law, but this pattern isn't new.

Part of the problem stems from imbalances in the system. The Coastal Commission lacks the basic regulatory power to impose fines and tickets for access violations. Property owners see this and take the rules less seriously.

Improved enforcement would benefit all sides, though powerful interests have repeatedly line up against it. Assembly Speaker Toni Atkins, D-San Diego, carried a bill last year that would have allowed the commission to impose fines. It failed in the last days of the session. It should be revived. Perhaps a narrower version, aimed at just access penalties, would be more successful.

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service