David Mas Masumoto: If Steinbeck were a farmer

FresnoApril 26, 2014 

The Grapes of Wrath

Illustration by SW Parra

Seventy-five years ago, John Steinbeck published "Grapes of Wrath," a tale about the plight of displaced Okies and their journey from Dust Bowl Oklahoma to the Central Valley of California, where they hoped to find work and a new life. When I first read "Grapes of Wrath" in high school, I was stunned to see a side of our valley, our farms and our people I had not imagined. A land of plenty contrasting with the plight of farmworkers. The constant struggle of poverty while trying to scratch out a living in our dirt. Hunger in a land where growing food is driven by business and money.

Steinbeck wrote his seminal work during the Great Depression, an era of great suffering. "Grapes of Wrath" examined the crushing economic forces on the human spirit and the search for dignity.

But what if Steinbeck was a farmer who wrote today? How might we re-envision his words as he rewrites his books?

Steinbeck might be my neighbor and I believe we'd trade stories, trying to make sense of a crazy world of farming. We would talk about an economic system that drives the price of food lower and lower. We struggle as farmers in a cheap food system. When "Grapes of Wrath" was published, Americans spent 35% of their income on food. In the 1960s, it had dropped to less than 20%. Today it's under 10% and a seemingly never-ending demand to grow food cheaper and cheaper. What's good for the consumer squeezes us farmers. We need to simply work harder.

Readers often forget that the Joad family in "Grapes of Wrath" were displaced farmers and were not always farmworkers. Arriving in California, they sought a place of their own, not unlike the immigrant farm story repeated over and over in our valley. My grandparents arrived in the 1900s from Japan, aliens in a foreign land. They, like the Joads, were displaced from the farm in their homeland. Once in America, they faced a hostile land filled with discrimination and Alien Land Laws that prevented, specifically, "Orientals" from land ownership.

Steinbeck the farmer might write a tale of new immigrants, the Hmong and other refugees from Southeast Asia or the Sikh farmers from Punjab, India, or Armenians from Eastern Europe. Instead of a clash between farmworkers and farmers, he might pen a new novel about class struggle: the small guy verses the machinery of capitalism. The destructive power of economic privilege and power over the "little guy" might become a rallying cry for the new Steinbeck.

The new "Grapes of Wrath" may also focus on a revolution on the farm for the past century: the epic shift from horses to tractors. The adoption of the new technology of mechanization can be depicted in an almost perfect economic curve, a graph with a giant "X" with tractors steadily replacing horses from the early 1900s to the present.

The revolution meant vast numbers of farmworkers were displaced — but equally as significant, they were absorbed into an ever-expanding urban industrial work- force. Tens of thousands of laborers were more than happy to leave the land for the bright and prosperous lights of the city. From one perspective, mechanization on the farm was only bad if you were a horse.

Steinbeck the farmer might write about the crushed hopes of those working hard with a fleeting dream of prosperity. I once wrote about finding torn lottery tickets in my fields, discarded hopes from our workers. I don't play the lottery — the odds are stacked against you. But I also can't share the same dreams as my workers. As they remind me, I already own a farm.

If Steinbeck were a farmer, race would be a major issue. When "Grapes of Wrath" was written, the America of the 1930s was 90% white and only 1.5% Latino. By 2010, whites were 72% and Latinos had grown to 17%. In California, the percentage of whites and Latinos are now almost the same, with Asians at 15%.

Over the past century, waves of immigrants filled our valley's fields. Cheap labor fueled the rapid and successful expansion of our agrarian base. A common theme was often the tension between those at the bottom fighting for the scraps left for them.

Yet all these characters may have journeyed a common path: a search for home. An eternal optimism permeates our lands, a collective narrative about the human spirit to work the earth and plant roots. Dreams were embedded in the hardpan of our soils.

The new Joad family from the "Grapes of Wrath" would now be a Latino family from Mexico, crossing physical and emotional borders. Their route would be along the back roads, perhaps even the Route 66 of today, still journeying off the main highways. The new Joads would be part of an invisible population whose forgotten hands continue to pick and harvest our foods. Steinbeck the farmer would be fighting for immigration reform, knowing firsthand the role farmworkers play in our food system.

Steinbeck the farmer would still be passionate about writing stories of connection, about people who are not rich with money but wealthy in relationships. He would share in a story of people on the land, and our quest to scratch out a living in this green valley of dreams.

Award-winning author and organic farmer David Mas Masumoto of Del Rey writes about the San Joaquin Valley and its people. Email: masmasumoto@gmail.com.

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service