Ask Amy: In-laws make family's life 'a living hell'

FresnoMarch 17, 2014 

Dear Amy: A year ago my husband was laid off and had trouble finding work.

Due to how long it took for him to find another job we had to give up our apartment and move in with my in-laws. We pay rent and help pay for food. My life has become a living hell. My brother-in-law has been verbally and physically abusive toward my husband and me. He is bipolar and his parents act like his behavior is normal.

My mother-in-law treats me as if I'm a maid. I'm blamed whenever something goes wrong. She has also tried to push us about how we should raise our two sons.

When we ask her to trust us to do what is right for them (they are well cared for) she tells us that they live under her roof and therefore will be raised as she sees fit.

We are looking for another place to live that we can afford, but until then what can I do to keep from losing my mind?

I have tried talking, begging, crying and yielding but no matter what we do we are treated like unwelcome pests. How can I keep the peace without just staying away from them for the rest of my life?

— Lost

Dear Lost: This situation might also be overwhelming for your in-laws, but if your mother-in-law is reacting by mistreating you, this is indefensible. If you and your children were locked in a cage with a tiger, I wouldn't tell you to beg the tiger not to hurt you, but to stay as calm as possible and avoid the tiger until you can escape.

You should get the kids out of the house every day. Visit your local library, both to give the kids the opportunity to do puzzles and pick out books, but also for you to research ways to change your living situation.

Your family might qualify for a housing voucher or other benefits because of your lower income. You should use every available opportunity. These benefits exist so families like yours can work your way back to independence.

Until you move, do your best to avoid the tiger. You don't say what role your husband plays in this dynamic, but he should step up his own efforts to move out, quickly.

Dear Amy: My grandson and his fiancée faced the typical wedding nightmare of trying to please all of their family members. Their solution: They flew to Las Vegas, rented a car and went through a drive-thru wedding — just the two of them. They never got out of the car!

Everything has been fine since. There are simple solutions to almost every problem.

— Proud gramps

Dear Proud: I completely agree.


You can contact Amy Dickinson via email at, follow her on Twitter @askingamy or "like" her on Facebook.

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service