EDITORIAL: California high court makes right call on insulin at school

Drug is designed to be injected by non-health care providers.

August 17, 2013 

The California Supreme Court ruled that properly trained volunteers at public schools are capable of administering insulin to children.

JAMES ESTRIN — NYT

In an ideal public education system, there'd be a nurse in every school. But as the California Supreme Court acknowledged earlier this week and as the numbers show, California schools are far from perfect.

Here are some relevant numbers: California has 2,800 public school nurses, one for every 2,200 of 6 million public school students. Only 5% of the public schools have a full-time school nurse, and 26% have no nurse at all.

Here's another number that is especially important: 14,000. That's the number of public school students who have diabetes and may require insulin shots.

Unions and associations representing nurses in California and from across the country took the absolutist position before California's high court that only nurses could administer insulin injections.

But in a unanimous decision, the justices sided with the California Department of Education and the American Diabetes Association, and rebuked the American Nurses Association and other unions representing nurses.

The justices determined that properly trained volunteers at public schools are perfectly capable of administering insulin, so long as the children's physicians and parents authorize it.

Insulin is designed to be administered by non-health care providers, including children themselves.

Many nurses have sincere concerns that volunteers, no matter how well-trained, put children at risk. But by advocating that nurses exclusively administer insulin, nurses put schools in the position of having to hire more nurses. That's hardly a coincidence.

It also should be noted that nurses organizations are battling right now in the Legislature to expand their "scope of practice" over medical procedures. How can nurses take a rigid stand on administering insulin when they are criticizing physicians for their rigid opposition to expanding scope of practice?

In this case, parents of four diabetic children filed a federal lawsuit alleging that the Fremont and San Ramon Valley school districts failed to comply with federal law by not providing insulin for their children. The U.S. Justice Department intervened in the California case, siding with the California Department of Education and American Diabetes Association that California law authorized volunteers to provide insulin.

The unanimous decision issued Monday also should put to rest any lingering doubts about whether properly trained volunteers can administer other medication, such as one used to combat epilepsy. Over the objection of the California Nurses Association, the Legislature approved a bill two years ago authorizing volunteers to administer the anti-seizure drug.

Every child deserves an education, including children who have conditions that require that medication be administered during school hours.

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service