TRUDY RUBIN: Mandela should be cloned

FresnoJune 15, 2013 

Listening to reports of Nelson Mandela's failing health, I can't help thinking how different the world would be if the former South African leader could have been cloned.

So many times, in countries plagued by sectarian conflicts and bloodshed, I've heard people say: "If only we had a Mandela."

Mandela's genius was his ability to forgive former enemies, along with a charisma that persuaded his black countrymen to do likewise — and convinced his white countrymen that he meant what he said.

Such generosity of spirit is so rarely found among leaders of other troubled nations — think Syria or Iraq — as to be almost unique to Mandela. In tribal cultures, forgiveness is too often seen as weakness; the pursuit of justice is too often confused with the pursuit of vengeance. This leads to ethnic cleansing and civil war.

Yet Mandela's acts of forgiveness — as the leader who negotiated his country's transition to black rule and served as its first black president, from 1994 to 1999 — were not the product of sainthood. They were at the core of a visionary strategy developed during decades in prison. It is a strategy that could save many countries from disaster if it were followed. But without a Mandela-like leader, it can't succeed.

I spoke to Mandela about his strategy in an interview in Johannesburg in 2000. The then-81-year-old reflected on why he chose pragmatism over revenge.

"The leadership of the ANC (African National Congress), who spent 30 years in exile or went underground or were in prison, have no time for revenge," Mandela said firmly. "They know they pass through life only once and want to use (their time) to solve the problems of their country. That is why we avoided bloodshed and confounded the prophets of doom.

"We had the ability to resolve the confrontation between our emotions and our brains, which said, 'Why slaughter each other when we can sit down and negotiate?' " Why indeed?

Mandela said he developed his strategy during his 27 years in prison, 18 of them in harsh conditions on Robben Island, off Capetown. I visited his tiny cell with Ahmed Kathrada, a former ANC prison-mate of Mandela's who recalled: "When we landed at the prison, one official said, 'In five years, no one will remember the name Mandela.' "

Unbowed, Mandela used those years to plan how a multiracial South Africa might one day function. How did he persuade long-suffering South African blacks to accept reconciliation with the whites who had oppressed them? "People normally take their cue from the leadership," Mandela responded.

To grasp the significance of this man, you only need look at what is happening in states that desperately need a Mandela but aren't lucky enough to have one.

Just imagine if there had been an Iraqi Mandela, a leader from the Shiite majority willing to work with, if not fully forgive, the Sunni minority that had oppressed his sect for decades. That country might now be knitting itself together and fully developing its oil riches. Instead, Iraq's Shiite leadership, paranoid and vengeful, is squeezing an angry Sunni minority back into sectarian war.

Or imagine if there were a Syrian opposition leader with the courage and credibility to convince members of Bashar al-Assad's minority Alawite sect that his exit wouldn't lead to their expulsion.

If, if, if ... The absence of such pragmatic visionaries elsewhere only highlights the good fortune of South Africans in having had such a leader.

And it explains the concern of many that, in the absence of Mandela's moral stature and calming charisma, even South Africa might start falling apart. Let's hope that his memory will sustain his vision for his own country.


Trudy Rubin is a columnist for the Philadelphia Inquirer. Readers may write to her at: Philadelphia Inquirer, P.O. Box 8263, Philadelphia, Pa. 19101, or by email at

The Fresno Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service